Key takeaways
- Measure twice, including clearance: Most of these run 15 to 20 inches wide, but you also need three to four inches of breathing room behind and above the unit. Under-cabinet installs are where good purchases go wrong.
- Match capacity to your actual cooking: A 2-slice oven is right for toast, bagels, and single portions. A 4-slice fits a small pizza or a sheet of vegetables. Go 6-slice only if you regularly cook for two or more.
- Decide whether air fry earns its space: If you already own an air fryer, skip the feature and buy a simpler oven. If you don’t, a 5-in-1 model consolidates two appliances into one outlet.
- Prefer dials if you’ll use it daily: Mechanical knobs are faster, quieter, and outlast touch panels. Digital controls make sense mainly if you want precise low-temperature settings.
- Choose a finish you can clean and live with: Stainless reads intentional next to almost any rental cabinetry; matte black disappears on dark counters. Both need a removable crumb tray to stay presentable.
What's inside
The BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven is the best overall toaster oven under $150 for renters and small households, with the BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD as the budget runner-up. One handles five cooking jobs in a footprint that respects a galley counter; the other does the daily toast-and-reheat work for the price of a takeout order.
Rental kitchens are an exercise in negotiation. You inherit a landlord-grade range that runs 25 degrees hot, one usable outlet near the backsplash, and roughly 18 linear inches of counter you actually want to give up. A toaster oven solves more of that than people expect: it preheats in minutes, skips heating the whole apartment in August, and in most cases replaces a separate toaster and air fryer entirely. This guide covers six sub-$150 models worth putting on a small counter, how to size one to your space, and which pick fits which kind of cook.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best For | Standout Feature | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven | Overall value in small kitchens | 5-in-1 cooking including air fry | See live rating above |
| BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD | Tight budgets and first apartments | Simple dial controls, 15.47-inch width | See live rating above |
| Elite Gourmet ETO236 Compact 2-Slice | Studios and dorm counters | Smallest footprint with 15-minute timer | See live rating above |
| BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS Convection | Baking and even reheating | Natural convection airflow | See live rating above |
| BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven | Two-person households and batch cooking | 6-slice capacity with air fry basket | See live rating above |
How to Choose a Toaster Oven Under $150 for Renters and Small Households
- Measure twice, including clearance: Most of these run 15 to 20 inches wide, but you also need three to four inches of breathing room behind and above the unit. Under-cabinet installs are where good purchases go wrong.
- Match capacity to your actual cooking: A 2-slice oven is right for toast, bagels, and single portions. A 4-slice fits a small pizza or a sheet of vegetables. Go 6-slice only if you regularly cook for two or more.
- Decide whether air fry earns its space: If you already own an air fryer, skip the feature and buy a simpler oven. If you don’t, a 5-in-1 model consolidates two appliances into one outlet.
- Prefer dials if you’ll use it daily: Mechanical knobs are faster, quieter, and outlast touch panels. Digital controls make sense mainly if you want precise low-temperature settings.
- Choose a finish you can clean and live with: Stainless reads intentional next to almost any rental cabinetry; matte black disappears on dark counters. Both need a removable crumb tray to stay presentable.
The Best Toaster Ovens Under $150 for Renters and Small Households, Reviewed
Best Overall: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven
This is the pick for the renter who wants one appliance to handle toast, roasted vegetables, reheated pizza, and crispy frozen snacks. The 4-slice capacity is the sweet spot for one or two people, and the air fry function is genuinely useful rather than a spec-sheet flourish.
Best Budget: BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD Toaster Oven
A no-nonsense 15.47-inch oven for anyone furnishing a first apartment or replacing a dead thrift-store unit. Best for cooks who need reliable toast, melts, and reheating without paying for convection or air fry modes they’d never touch.
Best Premium: Elite Gourmet ETO236 Compact 2-Slice Toaster Oven
Premium here means precision in a very small package: a tidy black-finish micro-oven with a 15-minute timer that suits studios, dorms, and offices where counter space is measured in inches. Ideal for solo cooks who cook small and value a clean, unobtrusive silhouette.
Best for Baking and Even Reheating: BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS Convection
The natural convection airflow gives you noticeably more even browning, which matters for cookies, roasted potatoes, and anything you’d otherwise have to rotate halfway through. Best for renters whose built-in oven bakes unevenly and who want stainless steel that looks deliberate.
Best for Two-Person Households: BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven
The largest pick here, and the one to buy if you cook full dinners rather than snacks. Best for couples and roommates who want to skip the main oven on weeknights and still fit a 9-inch pizza or a tray of chicken thighs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a toaster oven really replace an air fryer?
For most home cooking, yes. The 5-in-1 models here circulate hot air the same way, and the flat rack is easier to load than a basket. Dedicated air fryers still crisp slightly faster in smaller batches.
How much counter space do I need?
Plan for the oven’s width plus about four inches of clearance behind it and above it. In a galley kitchen, a 2-slice model is often the difference between usable prep space and none.
Is a combination toaster and toaster oven worth it?
If you eat toast every morning and dislike the results from a rack, the Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Toaster Oven with a long-slot 2-slice toaster is the space-saving answer. It consolidates two appliances into one outlet.
Will these trip a rental circuit?
Most draw 1,200 to 1,500 watts. Avoid sharing an outlet with a coffee maker or microwave, and don’t run them off a lightweight extension cord.
Final Thoughts
For most renters and small households, the BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven is the smartest single purchase, consolidating two appliances into one modest footprint. Choose the TO1313SBD if you want dependable basics at the lowest cost, or the Elite Gourmet ETO236 when every square inch of counter is contested.
